Welcome to StayInColumbus!
Whether you're looking for a luxury historic home, a pet-friendly retreat, or an efficient studio in a walkable neighborhood, we hope you'll find the perfect stay here.

Our listings feature privately owned properties, all hosted by our team at StayInColumbus. By booking directly through our site, you’ll enjoy the best rates—no hefty service fees like on Airbnb or VRBO!  You'll rent directly from the property owner, and as part of the process, you’ll be required to sign an electronic rental agreement and upload a photo ID matching your payment method. This step can be easier on a phone or tablet, where you can quickly snap a picture of your ID.

Need something specific?
If you’re not finding the right fit or have a unique request (such as recurring bookings, week-to-week, or month-to-month stays), let us know!  We’re always adding new properties and might have the perfect place for you.

Interested in working with us?
Learn more about the services we provide here and reach out if you'd like to chat!

24 properties  

The Carriage House at The Circus House

2 Bedrooms • 3 Baths (2 full, 1 half) • Sleeps 2-4
Allows pets Internet Fireplace
Perched at the northwest corner of Goodale Park, the "Circus House" and its adjacent carriage house are a Columbus landmark. This home, originally built for the owner's horses and carriage, has long since been converted to a private residence, with:
✓Two bedrooms upstairs, each with en suite bathroom
✓Private driveway parking for two vehicles
✓Unique features, like the original triangular windows (made for the horses to stick their heads out)

Photos Details Inquire

Highland House Columbus

2 Bedrooms • 2 Baths (1 full, 1 half) • Sleeps 3-6
Allows pets Internet

Highland House Columbus is a historic home that has been professionally decorated and beautifully blends original character with modern amenities. Located within walking distance to many of Columbus's best bars, restaurants and attractions it's the perfect place to stay!

Be our guests and enjoy:
✓ Prime location in the heart of Victorian Village
✓ Walking distance to the Short North
✓ Historic single-family home

Photos Details Inquire

The House on the Hill

2 Bedrooms • 1 Bath • Sleeps 3-4
Allows pets Internet
✓Morning coffee from the patio on top of the hill
✓Unique home with a style that will inspire you
✓Private driveway and off-street parking (with EV charging!)
✓Central Clintonville location

Photos Details Inquire

The Top of the Stairs: Chic Loft on 3rd Ave

1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • Sleeps 2-3
Internet
Climb 38 steps and unwind in our loft apartment on 3rd Ave, just half a block from High St. and the Short North's vibrant dining and nightlife scene. Private exterior entrance into the staircase to the loft. Enjoy:
✓ Stunning unique space - featured on the 2024 Short North Tour of Homes!
✓ Friendly owners live downstairs (on the 1st and 2nd floors)
✓ King-size bed; TV on bedroom wall
✓ Granite countertops & fully equipped kitchen
✓ One reserved parking spot on the property

Photos Details Inquire

The Little Blue Cottage - Fast WiFi

2 Bedrooms • 1 Bath • Sleeps 4
Allows pets Internet

✓Standalone Single-Family Home
✓Vibrant Short North Arts District
✓Reserved Parking Spot
✓Private Outdoor Patio

Coming in just under 1000 square feet and built in the early 1900s, this was a "tiny house" before they were cool. This home is one block west of Neil Ave. in historic Victorian Village.

Pet fees: Please see House Rules.

Photos Details Inquire

The Loft on Lundy

1 Bedroom • 1 Bath • Sleeps 2-4
Internet
Enjoy the historic character of the popular Short North Arts District from The Loft on Lundy:
✓ Private loft apartment above a garage (no shared walls)
✓ Reserved off-street parking for one vehicle - a premium in this area!
✓ Unique touches of vintage character (stained-glass windows!)
✓ Balcony with outdoor dining for two
✓ Prime location! Walk to the corner of Buttles and High in 3 minutes, or to the convention center in 10 minutes (0.5 miles).

Photos Details Inquire

The Yellow Porch House

3 Bedrooms • 2 Baths (1 full, 1 half) • Sleeps 4-6
Internet
Looking for modern updates perfectly blended with original character? Be our guest at The Yellow Porch House! Step from the gingerbread front porch onto the original pine wood floors of the dining room, and you'll feel right at home:
✓ Prime location in the heart of Victorian Village
✓ Historic single-family home
✓ One reserved off-street parking space

Photos Details Inquire

The Columbus Cape Cod Cottage | 1st Floor Beds!

3 Bedrooms • 1 Bath • Sleeps 6-10
Allows pets Internet
The Columbus Cape Cod Cottage has been professionally designed and fully equipped for a comfortable stay. Be our guest and enjoy:
✓ A fully-stocked and comfortable home - the owners stay here every few months to visit family and are always making upgrades!
✓ Easy parking: driveway for 2 vehicles (stacked) with EV charger! Free street parking also.
✓ Sleeps 8-10 guests! Three bedrooms: king + queen + queen, plus a trundle bed in the loft (two twins), and a sleeper sofa.

Photos Details Inquire

The Pinball House

3 Bedrooms • 3 Baths (2 full, 1 half) • Sleeps 5-7
Allows pets Internet Fireplace
Discover the Pinball House, a serene getaway situated on a quiet Cul-de-Sac in Columbus. Key features include:
✓ 3 bedrooms: 1 with a king bed and private bath, 1 with a queen bed, and 1 with bunk beds
✓ Pinball room in the basement (free!)
✓ Spacious fenced backyard for kids and dogs to play
✓ Conveniently located 10 minutes from Ohio State University, Downtown, Easton, and Polaris shopping areas
✓ On-site laundry for added convenience

Photos Details Inquire

Hudson Cottage | Fast WiFi!

2 Bedrooms • 1 Bath • Sleeps 3-5
Allows pets Internet
Hudson Cottage is a charming single-story retreat just north of The Ohio State University, featuring:
✓ Two bedrooms, one with a king bed, the other with a twin-over-full bunk bed
✓ 60" TV in open living/dining area with premium audio
✓ Steps to High St. restaurants, brunch, and night life
✓ 20-minute walk to Ohio Stadium
✓ Pet-friendly, with a fully fenced-in yard. Yard is mostly mulch (with some plants and concrete - no grass).

Photos Details Inquire

Charming Townhouse | Short North Arts District

2 Bedrooms • 1 Bath • Sleeps 3-4
Internet Fireplace
This charming and cozy townhouse is located on Kerr St. in historic Italian Village:
✓Central location (1/4 mile from convention center / 7-minute walk)
✓Two bedrooms (queen, two twins)
✓Permit parking (on street) for one vehicle ($3/night extra)
✓Stocked kitchen with cooking essentials and coffee
✓Plenty of old house charm with original mantels, woodwork, and doors

Photos Details Inquire

Central Townhouse | Walk to Convention Center

3 Bedrooms • 1 Bath • Sleeps 3-6
Internet
This central townhouse is located on the charming Kerr St. in historic Italian Village:
✓Walk to Convention Center (only 1/4 mile away / 7-minute walk)
✓Three bedrooms (all with queen beds)
✓Permit parking (on street) for one vehicle ($3/night extra)
✓Stocked kitchen with cooking essentials and coffee
✓Plenty of old house charm with original mantels, woodwork, and doors

Photos Details Inquire

1 – 12 of 24 places to stay